Coordinating Mechanical Systems in BIM: Rerouting Piping for Clashes

Addressing Clashes in Mechanical Systems: Rerouting Piping for Coordination

In a large BIM project, necessary coordination often requires some rerouting of the mechanical system. This article details a step-by-step process of examining a portion of a mechanical system and adjusting its configuration to prevent clashes and ensure proper functioning.

Key Insights

  • The article explains how to insert and link a Revit file to a mechanical system, set its positioning, and manage its visibility and reference type in a BIM project.
  • Upon inspection of the Level 2 piping plan, the need for rerouting piping to avoid clashes with ductwork is identified.
  • The article also provides a practical guide on how to adjust the elevation of branching lines, be mindful of potential obstructions like lights, and maintain the desired height of the piping plan.

Note: These materials offer prospective students a preview of how our classes are structured. Students enrolled in this course will receive access to the full set of materials, including video lectures, project-based assignments, and instructor feedback.

In the last video, we completed our sprinklers and Piping Plan. Everything is fully connected and our system is good to go. However, usually on a large BIM project such as this, there's going to be some coordination.

So what we're going to do is take a look at a portion of a mechanical system and see if we have to reroute some of our piping. So let's go to Insert and find Link Revit and go to where your Downloads folder is, your BIM324 file downloads, and find the Link Revit file. And let's look for the VDCI MEP Mechanical Coordination.

And let's have the positioning set to Internal Origin-to-Internal Origin. Go ahead and click Open. Now in this case, it's updating to the current version.

So just let it do its thing. Okay, we're getting this note, it's set to Overlay; nested links may not appear. Let's see what happens.

Let's go ahead and hit Close. Okay, so we do see it there. Now if you do run into a problem with visibility, you can go to Manage > Manage Links.

Learn Construction

  • Nationally accredited
  • Create your own portfolio
  • Free student software
  • Learn at your convenience
  • Authorized Autodesk training center

Learn More

And here's the link that we brought in. And the reference type, you can change from Overlay to Attachment. In either case, I'm able to see the model.

Now if we zoom in, I am on the Level Two Piping Plan. If we look here, it looks like our main is in a good spot. We are away from this ductwork here.

We should be okay there. However, it does look like this large duct—if we zoom in—we might be having some clashes in this area.

So let's take a section view and take a look at what's going on. I'm going to grab this one and I will pull it to about right here and go to View. And if I zoom in, we can see the elevation of these branch lines is running through this ductwork.

Here's our two-and-a-half-inch main. We definitely can't be doing this. So usually ductwork stays where it is, and piping has to route around it.

There's a little bit of give and take. But since we have some room up above the ceiling here, I think we can easily adjust what's going on. So let's go back to our Level Two Piping Plan and let's take a look at our main.

This piece right here—we're running through the ductwork. Let's take our other section looking in the other direction. I'll take this guy.

Let me flip it. I'm going to extend it a little larger. Okay.

And pull it down to that right here. Let's take a look. Yeah.

We have some opening here, but we should be careful because there might be some lights in the way as well that might affect our branch lines. So right now we are set to 10 feet 6 inches. Why don't we set this to 9 feet 8 inches. And it might take a while. Okay.

We are still above the ceiling. We definitely don't want to be at or below. Let's extend this out a little bit.

Okay. So far it looks good. Let's go to our Level Two Piping Plan.

Now, unfortunately, by doing that, we set our entire run of main to 9 feet 8 inches, which we don't want because we were at 10 feet 6 inches. So here's what we're going to do instead. Let's undo all of that. Keep going.

Okay. Now we're back at 10 feet 6 inches.

photo of Derek Cutsinger

Derek Cutsinger

BIM Instructor/Coordinator

Derek’s background is in both education and MEP. He earned his BA in Music Education from San Diego State University and is also a TEFL certified English language instructor. In addition to educational roles, he is also an experienced fire protection design engineer and has extensive knowledge in many programs and processes used in AEC industries. He brings his unique and eclectic skillset to VDCI as their Curriculum Coordinator. In his free time he can be found weightlifting in his garage, hanging out with his wife and pug, or painting and drawing in his studio.

  • BA Music Education – San Diego State University
  • MA Applied Linguistics (in process) – San Diego State University
  • TEFL Certified English Language Instructor
  • NICET 1 Certification
More articles by Derek Cutsinger

How to Learn Construction

Learn fundamental construction skills, including project planning, safety protocols, and management techniques, with expert-led training.

Yelp Facebook LinkedIn YouTube Twitter Instagram